Fugitive Fragments

by Mike McGuire

Book review: Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick

silver_linings_playbook_cover_book2Did you hear the one about the Irishman who read the book AFTER he saw the movie? Well, he found a different and much more interesting story. And it wasn’t a Rom-Com.

Quick’s debut novel is a brilliant inceptive; a gifted work. It is told in the voice of the main character, thirty-something former teacher Pat, a mental patient who has just been released from a psychiatric facility into his parents care. The use of Pat’s voice for narration is inspired. His childlike utterances are both frank and funny. The author brings the reader inside the jumbled mind of a recovering psychotic who thinks in absolutes and idiosyncrasies. His prominent absolute is his belief in the silver linings that his mother told him about as a child. Pat believes that everything in his life will turn out right if he focuses on improving his mind, keeping fit and being kind (“…kind instead of right”). He sees his life as a real-time movie, playing out to his anticipated ‘Hollywood’ happy ending.

His focal fixate is getting his wife Nikki back but he is prohibited from contact with her by court order. Enter Tiffany, a young widow with her own mental baggage (and agenda) who offers to help him in his quest for Nikki in return for a favor – she needs him to partner her in a dance competition. She has observed him training and considers him physically suitable for her demanding choreography. As they practice for the event we are drawn deeper into the principal characters and their families. Pat’s caring mother is counter-balanced by a father who is emotionally numbed by his son’s illness and ignores him. The barrier between father and son can be eased somewhat by their common allegiance to the local football team and the reader is given a passing education in the frenzied culture of the American National Football League. Tiffany’s family protect her secrets as they try to protect her from herself.

The curtains of Pat’s life slowly draw open to reveal the forgotten genesis of his mental condition. This emergence also alludes to his growing recovery and while Tiffany’s dance therapy has a healing effect on her, both still have their demons to deal with.

Unlike the movie, this is a book about the experiences of the mentally ill and people who touch their lives. It is about flawed people – including ones without mental health conditions. It has the blended bitter-sweetness of being poignant, funny, sad and aspirational. Quick – an English teacher – has written fluidly in language that is easy to read and the chapters are kept short. The plot includes suspense and there are a number of unexpected revelations. Far from romantic, the book suggests a relationship between two people that is based on tenderness, need and compatibility.

There are some parallels with Mark Haddon’s lovely, ‘The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time’. Readers who recognize the ‘unreliable narrator’ style will feel right at home.

Single Post Navigation

18 thoughts on “Book review: Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick

  1. I’m not sure which I enjoyed more…your thought provoking and insightful review or your comments lol! I’ve just decided….both! ;)

    • Yunno I never considered that Christina but I suppose that content and comment could indeed be seen as a package. No lol – now I’m going to have to be even more conscious of my replies!

      • LOL It is funny how many people do actually read the comments….I do tend to…if only to not be repetitive! In this case both went together better than peanut butter and jelly…unless you don’t like peanut butter…or jelly…then I’ll have to think of a better metaphor haha!

  2. I’ve been meaning to read this book, and now you’ve convinced me to do so. I recently saw the film, and was disappointed, given all the Oscar buzz. (But I’m frequently disappointed by Oscar buzz so I don’t know why this surprises me.) Well, off to the library…

  3. Mike,
    I’m glad I read this. I really wanted to see the movie, but you made me want to read the book first. Well-written review, BTW

    • Thank you muchly. You’ll still enjoy the movie after the book provided you don’t expect a match – the Cooper/Lawrence pairing is very entertaining to watch (and a laugh).

  4. I loved the movie looked up the writer. I was pleased to see it was a book first.
    You hit on the most remarkable fact. The writer was an English teacher and yet he didn’t overwork his words. The simplicity of thought came through in the movie and therein lies its charm.

    • Perhaps his is a trait that comes from interacting with children but you’re quite right, he would have had to consciously decide the language in advance. Another factor could be the unembellished voices of of the mentally ill.

  5. I have neither seen the film nor read the book, Mike. But I have read your illuminating review. And for that I thank you! I too have written a debut novel about mental illness (among other themes), and I from what you say my own work is the complete antithesis of Matthew Quick’s, ie “written fluidly in language that is easy to read and the chapters are kept short”. Hmm, I’m guessing you’ve put your finger on why Hollywood hasn’t been knocking on my door, offering options on post-theatrical release DVD sales etc. Ha! :)

  6. I tried numerous times to catch the lauded film in theatres but never managed to see it. Glad to have read your review, Mike. Definitely will read before I watch!

    • Good that you’ll read the book first Brent. The movie isn’t bad (quite good actually) just packaged differently to fit a box office genre. Lawrence’s Oscar winning performance is still worth seeing.

  7. It sounds deep and complex. Does it have a happy ending..

    • To the contrary, it is neither deep or complex N-L and sorry if I gave that impression. While I try not to give spoilers in my reviews I can indicate that it has a very acceptable ending.

  8. Thanks for reviewing this. I watched the film, thought it okay. But you’ve made me interested to read the book… provided I can find one without the film image on the book jacket. I do so hate those :-)

    • Being an author yourself I have no doubt that you’ll get much out of this fine book Jackie. Can’t do anything about the cover but if you get the eBook you can fashion/fasten your own coverart (:

Whaddya think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

My Invisible Crown

Impulsive writing from my inner Princess

Poet on the Farm

A Residency at Acton Scott Historic Working Farm 2014

ddwright

Author of Poetry 2Life: Youth. Struggle. Love. & Embracing: A Poetic Perspective

The Story Of A Guy

A Journey Through The Eyes Of A Guy

Book to the Future

More book than a mad 'orse

crossjover

The Tattletales of the Twister

Apoorv

A sidekick blog just to record my thoughts

The Ink Stain

Hi everyone! This is my blog, and this is where I post all of my stories. Writing is my favorite thing to do, and I love nothing more than this. I would appreciate it if you took the time to read my stories! If you like the blog, please share it with more people. Thank you!

Here

words on a page

subtlescrap

Gaurav jindal`s blog

writingwingsforyou

Marie Lukasik Wallace ~ passionate about life and writing and all things creative and poetic!

Steady Eye Shaky Bow

A girl aiming to find herself as she battles Rheumatoid Arthritis and the trials of being a teenager.

Something Like a Storybook

This is where Morgan Bradham shares stuff.

Maxima

Electronic thoughts Follow me and enjoy !

Soul Gatherings

Spiritual Moments in the Human Experience

The Fires Inside

A Literary Soul Scorching The Earth

The Breakdown of Taboo

Is Taboo Dying?

My Oeuvre

There is no agony other than bearing a untold story inside you.

Raised by Wolves

Selected musings of an Atlanta author.

Fall Into The Sky

And they danced with star-spangled eyes to music that only they could hear.

mindlessfloyd

A collection of nonsensical words thrown together

Maze of Musings

"Go into the arts. I’m not kidding. The arts are not a way to make a living. They are a very human way of making life more bearable. Practicing an art, no matter how well or badly, is a way to make your soul grow, for heaven’s sake. Sing in the shower. Dance to the radio. Tell stories. Write a poem to a friend, even a lousy poem. Do it as well as you possibly can. You will get an an enormous reward. You will have created something." - Kurt Vonnegut

jennalovestherain

I wait for rain, for the breath of heaven to descend.

Regarding Samuel

A writers blog

e l e c t r i c k f i l m

Sunflower Solace Farm

Displaced Homesteader Makin' Do in the City and Dreamin' Up Her Return

The Wistful Pessimist

Freedom. Beauty. Truth. Love. Silver.

Clearly Confused

Don't Die Wondering

Melbourne Poets Union

where poetry lives life to the fullest

Tall tales of fiction

Unedited works & scribbles

My Journey with Verse

Join me as I nose dive into unknown waters, and emerge, sometimes with pearls!

chrishancock789

A writing and photography blog...

Yay Words!

A celebration of language and the written word (with a little art on the side).

Fiddlbarb's Blog

Just another WordPress.com weblog

sundry folly

writing+photography from S.K. Benjamin 묘 All work comes from my body unless a credit is given.

Peace, love and patchouli

A blog of life according to me.

Suzy Blue - the blog

one blog for all the blogs

islandphoto8o8

Island photography and written words at their best.

fozzyfitness

Blogs on Everything in Life and fitness

The Poet Layabout

The collected works of an underrated genius

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,040 other followers

%d bloggers like this: